Please note that most putters have a scuffed edge the whole way round and that this is intentional. Gateway's molding process does not leave as smooth an edge as other manufacturers. The textured edge is a byproduct of not drying the plastic and is intentional as many people like the texture. There can be a few discs here and there where it’s too prevalent (especially on the more flexible plastic) for some people's taste but others enjoy that texture and feel it helps grab the chains.
As well, although these discs are new, they do not look brand new as a result of Gateway's molding process.